In 1994, a hundred cars stood on the roof of an Oakland car park. More than two hundred high school students sat inside them. Visitors moved from one car to the next, stopping to listen. Inside, the students talked about school, family and what lay ahead. There was no script. The performance was called The Roof Is on Fire. For the people walking across the roof, the experience depended on which car they stopped beside and where the conversation happened to be at that moment.
A seat in the room tells you very little about what someone is free to do there. The same goes online. You can put a question to a host in a live chat or choose a game at an online casino such as riverspin. When tenants in a Liverpool tower block began making webcasts, they could spend an hour on rent increases if they wanted to. The people with the rent bills could also be the people behind the camera.
The work before the performance
Forty students attended after-school planning sessions for The Roof Is on Fire, according to Suzanne Lacy’s Oakland Projects archive. Lacy and Chris Johnson also worked with teachers on media literacy lessons about how teenagers were portrayed and how they might represent themselves. By the time the cars pulled onto the roof, students had already helped organize the event. The choice to seat them facing one another gave the audience a job people could understand without a programme. Walk over, stop and listen.
So what is social practice art? It is art made through the relationships and decisions that develop when people work together. The artist might propose a form, such as a rooftop performance. The people involved give it a direction the artist could only partly plan. In Oakland, the students could take a conversation where they wanted to go. Anyone documenting the evening would have had to choose where to stand, just like everyone else.
Social practice art examples beyond the gallery
The first tenantspin webcasts grew out of a pilot with residents of Coronation Court. Tenants learned to run studio equipment and present programmes. Rent increases were one subject, beans on toast another. Both belonged on a channel whose presenters could decide for themselves what was worth an hour. In SUPERFLEX’s account of the project, tenant presenter Steve Thomas made his own comparison with two familiar British television hosts.
“I’M NO PAXMAN OR KILROY, BUT I’M DOING IT”
Steve Thomas, tenantspin presenter
In Houston’s Third Ward, seven Black artists began Project Row Houses in 1993. The project’s own history traces the influence of Houston artist John Biggers, whose work drew on the neighbourhood’s shotgun houses. The founders saw a use for houses that were standing empty. The houses became a base for art and for programmes including support for young mothers. A broadcast ends when someone cuts the feed. A row of houses asks for a different sort of commitment. Someone still has to open the doors the following week.
In Middlesbrough, the Gresham Neighbourhood Plan grew out of artist Isabel Lima’s work with local residents. In 2018, residents and other local stakeholders formed a forum and drew a boundary for the area they wanted to plan for. The council approved the forum and the area in 2019. The map gave the group something precise to bring into a planning process. The four projects put very different decisions in participants’ hands.
| Project | Setting | What people helped decide |
|---|---|---|
| The Roof Is on Fire | Oakland car park | What to discuss in front of an audience |
| tenantspin | Liverpool webcast studio | Which topics to put on air |
| Project Row Houses | Houston shotgun houses | How a row of buildings could serve the neighbourhood |
| Gresham Neighbourhood Plan | Middlesbrough planning forum | What area the proposed plan would cover |
Who can afford to take part
For Expectations, a later Oakland project, pregnant and parenting teenagers took part in a summer arts programme. Lacy’s archive lists what the organizers provided alongside the teaching. There was childcare on site. There was transport, lunch and a stipend. Those arrangements are easy to leave out of an exhibition label. For a student with a baby and a bus journey, they could be the reason the day was possible. A project budget can reveal whose time and labour the organizers have counted.
- The bus fare for the person coming from across town
- Childcare for the hours the group will actually meet
- Pay for people who prepare, host or translate a session
- Time for participants to check a recording before it goes out
- A way to contribute for someone who cannot use the venue
Money is one part of this. A webcast also needs someone who knows how to work the equipment. A planning forum needs people who can make sense of council documents and explain them to neighbours. In social art practice, these jobs shape who can change a proposal and who can only respond to one. Lima describes the Gresham board, which holds photographs and planning documents, as something the group can keep adding to.
“an archive in motion”
Isabel Lima, on the Gresham Neighbourhood Plan board
What a project leaves behind
A television documentary about the Oakland performance reached viewers who never set foot on the roof. The film could preserve some of what the students said. It could also give those conversations a running order that no visitor had experienced in quite the same way. After the public event, the record starts to have a life of its own. The person looking after it inherits choices about what people can find and whose account appears first.
| Record | What it can preserve | Decision it leaves open |
|---|---|---|
| Film | The voices of people in the room | Who can approve a new cut? |
| Webcast | What residents wanted to discuss | Who keeps the recordings available? |
| Boundary map | The area a forum agreed to represent | Who can propose a change? |
| Meeting notes | How a group reached a decision | Which details should stay private? |
Before the studio closes or the venue keys go back, a group can check what it agreed to do with the record. Getting a copy of a film may be simple. Asking for a name to come off a page is more delicate, especially if the page already has an audience. People can settle those details while they still know whom to ask.
- Give contributors a copy they can open and keep.
- Say who can correct a credit or take down a photograph.
- Note what the public can see and when access will end.
- Pass account access to the people taking over.
- Agree who will be paid for any work that continues.
On the Oakland roof, the audience could move on to another car at any time. The students could carry on talking. The scene offers a test for the next project that calls itself participatory. What can the people invited in do once they arrive? Can they set the subject, change the plan or keep the record? A project may be remembered for the image it left behind. Its participants may remember the first decision that was theirs to make.